Bibliographic description of the article
Lutsenko, A. V. «BLOODLESS» REVOLUTION / A. V. Lutsenko. – Text : direct // Innovative economics and society. – 2022. – № 3 (37). – С. 112-127

Abstract

This article is about social and economic situation in Russia close before the revolutionary events in 1917. Author analyzes strategies of main Russian political elites in situation of military crisis and Emperor’s power crush. Then author defines structural and functional parameters of state and zemstvo’s bureaucracy in situation of razrukha’s beginning. The complex of economic and foreign-political factors that caused razrukha, is shown: extremely large-scaled and high-intensive military mobilizations which helped Russia to take a half of Entente’s total military efforts were catastrophically combined with the aspirations of Britain and France to establish control over the empire's economy and with outright abuses of Russian «social activists» in army supplying. In this case author focuses on the specific practices of Russian military officials who «for the sake of friendship» gave out secret information to allies in the Entente. On the basis of Russian Empire government documents, the result of the unification of hostile external influences made by the German army and internal disorganization due to fatal mistakes of tsarist officials is demonstrated: the first mistake was the ill-considered evacuation of more than 6 million civilians from the frontline zone, the second one was rejection of the equalized-normalized vital goods distribution in the conditions of production decline and the third one was carrying out the autumn draft of 1916 during the harvest. Shown historical sources are proving that destructive strategies which began razrukha were based on specific «group egoism» of conservative and liberal political parties which attempted to take their own control over Russian Empire and to replace Tsar's authority by their leaders one. These sources are also disproving the myth about leading role of radical revolutionary political doctrines (Bolshevist, Social-Revolutionary and Aharchist one) in massive revolutionary movement evolution in summer and autmn of 1917. The final conclusion of article’s author is he overall cumulative effect of the accumulation of catastrophic mistakes, unprecedented abuses and military defeats naturally led to the paralysis of power and the fall of the authority of the monarchy, which has lost legitimacy in the eyes of Russia’s people.

References

Майер, Н. Служба в комиссариате юстиции и народном суде / Н. Майер. - Текст : непосредственный // Архив русской революции. - 1923. - Т. 8. - С. 56-109. @@Mayer N. Service in the Commissariat of Justice and the People's Court. Arkhiv russkoy revolyutsii - Archive of Russian Revolution, 1923, no. 8, pp. 56-109 (In Russian).
Милицын, С. В. Из моей тетради / С. В. Милицын. - Текст : непосредственный // Архив русской революции. - 1921. - Т. 2. - С. 143-193. @@Militsyn S. V. From my notebook. Arkhiv russkoy revolyutsii - Archive of Russian Revolution, 1921, no. 2, pp. 143-193 (In Russian).
Лукомский, А. С. Из воспоминаний / А. С. Лукомский. - Текст : непосредственный // Архив русской революции. - 1921. - Т. 2. - С. 14-44. @@Lukomskiy A. S. From memoirs. Arkhiv russkoy revolyutsii - Archive of Russian Revolution, 1921, no. 2, pp. 14-44 (In Russian).
Керсновский, А. А. История русской армии. В 4-х т. / А. А. Керсновский. - Москва : Голос, 1992-1994. @@Kersnovskiy, A. A. Istoriya russkoy armii (History of the Russian Army). In 4 vol. Moscow, Golos Publ., 1992-1994 (In Russian).
Спиридович, А. И. При царском режиме / А. И. Спиридович. - Текст : непосредственный // Архив русской революции. - 1928. - Т. 15. - С. 85-206. @@Spiridovich A.I. Spiridovich A. I. Under the Tsarist regime. Arkhiv russkoy revolyutsii - Archive of Russian Revolution, 1928, no. 15, pp. 85-206 (In Russian).
Блок, А. А. Последние дни старого режима / А. А. Блок. - Текст : непосредственный // Архив русской революции. - 1922. - Т. 4. - С. 5-54. @@Blok A. A. The last days of the old regime. Arkhiv russkoy revolyutsii - Archive of Russian Revolution, 1922, no. 4, pp. 5-54 (In Russian).
Родзянко, М. В. Крушение империи / М. В. Родзянко. - Текст: непосредственный // Архив русской революции. - 1926. - Т. 17. - С. 5-169. @@Rodzyanko M. V. The collapse of the Empire. Arkhiv russkoy revolyutsii - Archive of Russian Revolution, 1926. no. 17. pp. 5-169 (In Russian).
Петрункевич, И. И. Из записок общественного деятеля / И. И. Петрункевич. - Текст : непосредственный // Архив русской революции. - Т. 21. - 1934. - 472 с. @@Petrunkevich I. I. From the diaries of a public figure. Arkhiv russkoy revolyutsii - Archive of Russian Revolution. 1934, no. 21, 472 p (In Russian).
Кельсиев, В. И. Исповедь / В. И. Кельсиев. - Текст : непосредственный // Архив русской революции. - 1923. - Т. 11. - С. 169-310. @@Kel‘siev V. I. Confession . Arkhiv russkoy revolyutsii - Archive of Russian Revolution, 1923, no. 11, pp. 169-310 (In Russian).
Аврех, А. Я. П. А. Столыпин и судьбы реформ в России / А. Я. Аврех. - Москва : Политиздат, 1991. - 286 с. - Текст : непосредственный. @@Avrekh A. Ya. P.A. Stolypin i sud‘by reform v Rossii (P.A. Stolypin and the fate of reforms in Russia). Moscow: Political Publ., 1991, 286 p. (In Russian).
Гофштеттер, И. А. А воз и ныне там / И. А. Гофштеттер. - Текст : непосредственный // Новое время. - 1910. @@Gofshtetter I. A. And the cart is still there. Novoe vremya - New time, 1910 (in Russian).
Виноградов, К. Б. Дэвид Ллойд Джордж / К. Б. Виноградов. - Москва : Мысль, 1970. - 412 с. - Текст : непосредственный. @@Vinogradov K. B. Devid Lloyd Dzhordzh (David Lloyd George). Мoscow, Mysl‘, 1970, 412 p. (In Russian).
Палеолог, М. Царская Россия накануне революции / М. Палеолог. - Москва : Политиздат, 1991. - 492 с. - Текст : непосредственный. @@Paleolog M. Tsarskaya Rossiya nakanune revolyutsii (Tsarist Russia on the eve of the Revolution). Moscow, Political Publ., 1991, 492 p. (In Russian).
Лисовский, Ю. Лагерь Ля-Куртин / Ю. Лисовский. - Текст : непосредственный // Архив русской революции. - 1926. - Т. 17. - С. 256-279. @@Lisovskiy Yu. La Curtin Camp. Arkhiv russkoy revolyutsii - Archive of Russian Revolution, 1926, no. 17, pp. 256-279 (In Russian).
Яхонтов, А. Н. Тяжелые дни (Секретные заседания Совета Министров - 16 июля - 2 сентября 1915 года) / А. Н. Яхонтов. - Текст : непосредственный // Архив русской революции. - 1926 - Т. 18. - С. 5-136. @@Yakhontov A. N. Hard days (Secret meetings of the Council of Ministers - July 16 - September 2, 1915). Arkhiv russkoy revolyutsii - Archive of Russian Revolution, 1926, no. 18,
Записки белогвардейца-лейтенанта NN. - Текст : непосредственный // Архив русской революции. - 1923. - Т. 10. - С. 56-113. @@Notes of a White Guard lieutenant NN. Arkhiv russkoy revolyutsii - Archive of Russian Revolution, 1923, no. 10, pp. 56-113 (In Russian
Шишков, Ю. Упущенный шанс / Ю. Шишков. - Текст : непосредственный // Наука и жизнь. - 1991. - № 11. - С. 2-11. @@Shishkov Yu. A missed chance. Nauka i zhizn‘ - Science and Life, Moscow, 1991, no. 11, pp. 2-11 (In Russian).
Родзянко, М. В. Государственная Дума и февральская революция / М. В. Родзянко. - Текст : непосредственный // Архив русской революции. - 1923. - Т. 6. - С. 5-80. @@Rodzyanko M. V. The State Duma and the February Revolution. Arkhiv russkoy revolyutsii - Archive of Russian Revolution, 1923, no. 6, pp. 5-80 (In Russian).
Рапопорт, И. Полтора года в советском главке / Рапопорт И. - Текст : непосредственный // Архив русской революции. - 1921. - Т. 2. - С. 98-107. @@Rapoport I. A year and a half in the Soviet main committee. Arkhiv russkoy revolyutsii - Archive of Russian Revolution, 1921, no. 2, pp. 98-107 (In Russian).
Сироткин, В. И. Предисловие. Палеолог М. Царская Россия во время Мировой войны / В. И. Сироткин. - Москва : Международные отношения, 1991. - С. 5-16. - Текст : непосредственный. @@Sirotkin V. I. Preface Paleolog Tsarskaya Rossiya vo vremya Mirovoy voyny - Tsarist Russia during the World War, Мoscow, Foreign Affairs Publ., 1991, pp. 5-16 (In Russian).
Чаянов, А. В. Продовольственный вопрос. Лекции, читанные на курсах о подготовке работников по культурно-просветительской деятельности при Совете студенческих депутатов в апреле 1917 г. / А. В. Чаянов. - Москва : [Б.и.], 1917. - 56 с. - Текст : непосредственный. @@Chayanov A.V. Prodovol‘stvennyy vopros. Lektsii, chitannye na kursakh o podgotovke rabotnikov po kul‘turno-prosvetitel‘skoy deyatel‘nosti pri Sovete studencheskikh deputatov v aprele 1917 g. (Food issue. Lectures given at courses on the training of workers in cultural and educational activities at the Council of Student Deputies in April 1917). Moscow: [without publ.], 1917, 56 p. (In Russian).

Author

A. V. Lutsenko —
Ph. D. in History, professor of the Humanities and Social Sciences department, STI NRNU MEPhi.